“Something is Now Supposed to Grow Together”
I’ve been paying attention to Germany lately. And not just because my wife happens to be there visiting dear friends of ours who live in Bavaria (my daily act of spiritual discipline this week has been to attempt to suppress the feelings of jealousy that regularly flare up as I think about her wandering the streets of Munich while I clean the cat’s litter box and make dinner…). I’m also paying attention to Germany because this is the nation that was and remains a focal point of the refugee crisis that took a dramatic turn in early September with the discovery of Alan Kurdi’s body on a Turkish beach.
Since then, we’ve observed this wave of human beings from Syria, Iraq, Afghanistan, and elsewhere moving steadily into Europe looking for safety and a better future. More often than not, their destination was and remains Germany. And in those early days of the refugee crisis that now dominates the daily news, Germany responded in incredible ways. Chancellor Angela Merkel threw open the doors of her nation, saying that all who sought asylum would be welcomed. The numbers were astonishing. There was talk of anywhere between eight hundred thousand and a million people being absorbed into German cities and towns. There were inspirational scenes of crowds of Germans welcoming Syrian refugees at train stations in Munich, Berlin, Stuttgart… Germany was a global symbol of hospitality, of embracing the stranger. Germany was the bar that other nations were failing to rise to.
Here in Canada, Germany’s generosity was compared to the meager trickle of refugees that were allowed to dribble in to our nation due to what many consider to be our government’s unnecessarily restrictive policies. Why can’t Canada be more like Germany? I often heard in conversations about our project to bring Syrian refugees to our city. I heard it again just last week at a forum that I was invited to speak at. I recall saying something along the lines of what I often say when asked about Canada in comparison to Germany. Well, I don’t know about the numbers that Germany is considering. But I’m pretty sure that Canada can do more. A lot more.
I remain convinced that this is true. Canada can and must do more. I remain convinced that Germany acted admirably in those early days. But even at the time I wondered how this would all play out. As the breathless affirmation of Merkel and of Germany poured forth in corners of social media, I wondered how all of this would sound a few months or years down the line. I wondered what absorbing hundreds of thousands of people from cultures that look and sound and feel nothing like twenty-first century Germany would look like. I wondered if German people—good, compassionate, decent German people—would lose patience with their government’s decision, and begin to turn on the refugees. Rhetoric tends to race ahead of reality, particularly when the rhetoric is as high-minded as it was when people are responding and reacting to human suffering on a staggering scale.
And now, predictably, it seems that some of these realities are starting to materialize. A recent article in The Economist paints a sobering picture of German public opinion turning against Merkel, of communities struggling to integrate refugees or even house them as winter approaches, of classrooms being unable to cope with children who can’t speak the language, of clashes between competing groups at refugee camps, of asylum seekers struggling to fit into the German social and economic reality. These are massive challenges that will require enormous energies to adequately address going forward.
We can’t ignore what’s going on in Germany—particularly those of us who have been strong advocates of welcoming the stranger into our own nation and communities. I know that I have been among those who have appealed to high-minded ideals in advocating a response that is compassionate and wise. I know many will point to stories like the one in The Economist and say, “You see, we told you! Look at what’s happening over there! ‘Those people’ just don’t integrate well!” I know that many will point to Germany as an example of what we don’t want to happen here in Canada.
And so, how do we respond? What do we say? What do I say? I have poured forth so many words in this space about the refugee crisis and what it asks of us, as human beings, as Canadians, as Christians. Is it all just a bunch of idealistic noise? Some undoubtedly think so (several hundred commenters on a recent post, at the very least). But I remain hopeful. I think that our local group has a good plan of “families welcoming families” and are determined to walk with the people that arrive in our city far beyond the one-year requirement. We have past success stories in our churches and our city to point to and learn from. We know this can work.
But we also know that it’s not easy, and that romanticizing the process and drenching it with dewy-eyed rhetoric isn’t helpful either. We live in a point-and-click-activism culture where our compassion and good will is easily yanked around by the latest deliverances of social media. Germany reminds us that this is a long road that we have decided to walk. And it will likely be a hard one. Our situation in Canada bears little resemblance to the one faced by Germany, but wherever we are and however we are trying to respond, unless our efforts are animated by deep and settled convictions about what is possible and what it might require, they will probably not be successful.
German president Joachim Gauck has said that the present refugee crisis is the biggest challenge that Germany has faced since reunification in 1990. In a fascinating statement from the article referred to above, he says:
Just like in 1990 we’re all facing a challenge that will occupy us for generations. But unlike back then, something is now supposed to grow together that has not belonged together until now.”
I am obviously thinking far beyond the German context when I say that I am convinced that there are possibilities contained in those two little words, “until now.” How could I not? I am a follower of Jesus, after all—a follower of the one who brought together Jew and Gentile, who took hostile peoples and—impossibly!—grafted them into the same branch. I am a follower of the one who looked at things that did not “belong together” and made them grow into something beautiful and new. How could I not believe that similar things are possible for those who follow in his steps?
Interesting article as we soon go to the polls and elect a new government. You raised the question about Canada’s role. And you’re right on target. I’m bilingual (German-English) with a dual citizenship (Swiss-Canadian). So I’m aware what is going on in Germany and other European countries. There are many “right wing” movements in Germany and Switzerland. Just saw this morning a post by one of these movements who demand that Merkel should be hanged. So not all Germans “welcome” these refugees. But keep in mind for the last 30 years Germany hosts/invites “guest workers from Turkey. I think they’re around 3 million. Further to the current situation, Istanbul/Turkey has more Syrian refugees than all European countries together. Coming back to Canada, I do believe we’re controlled by fear, not by compassion. In December I’ll go for 2 weeks to Serbia helping serve these refugees!
Thanks for this, Christoph. I wish you all the best as you to Serbia! Such important work that you are doing.
There r many countries. Germany can’t b expected to do all the heavy lifting. I pray canada will pitch in next Tuesday when Harper becomes history
Sent from my iPhone
Yes, I think that there are many other nations in the world who could clearly do more.
We listened to Ursula Von Der Leyen on BBC Hardtalk. She is the German Defense Minister (has a fascinating bio). The full interview was 20 minutes and she is a humbling person to listen to. She is calm, thoughtful and most of all compassionate. The world needs more leaders like her for it would then be a place of much lower anxiety. Germany is a tower of peace and compassion
Thanks for the link! Will listen.
How could I not believe that things that do not belong together can grow together when I was a gentile and a stranger to the covenants of promise and I am now growing together with other strangers?
That is a miracle and the very valid questions and concerns raised by every side of this issue will require a miracle which we are no longer strangers to.
As you said, this will be a bumpy ride for everyone and will require a lot more than a mere form of Christlikeness that denies the power thereof. It will require nothing less than Christ’s omnipotent love. The question is are we ready to love not just indiscriminately but omnipotently? Not just with our words and emotions but be channels through whom God loves the stranger while stilling the storms that will rage and healing the wounds that will ensue.
The fact is when you choose love, you expose yourself to disastrous consequences and to being hurt, big time and you need nothing less than the power that raised Christ from death. It is that power we need to ensure we are not paying mere lip service to as we open our homes and hearts to strangers. The power that ensured that rather than suffer needlessly in laying down his life, Christ’s fatal wounds were not only healed, they are healing.
Yes. Well said.
My spirit is uncomfortable with equating German economic pragmatism as something like Christian love. Nor do I think any secular political party offers kingdom living now or eternal salvation later. My heart tells me that until those who perport to follow Christ actually work towards creating Christian communities apart from secular ones, we shall continue to live diluted, ( at best) illusory “Christian” lives.
I’m not equating the two, I’m simply reflecting upon the fact that the former can lead to clarification on the latter. Discipleship always takes place in a particular context; the shape that Christian love takes is always influenced by the social, political, economic, etc context in which we find ourselves.
Thank you Ryan! Yes we’re trying our best well knowing this is going to be very difficult, but like Fr. Merkel said, we are not in competition who is the most unfriendly country in Europe. Very much hoping that other countries will do their fair share.
I hope for the same, Petra. And it was so great to hear about your son playing basketball with the newcomers in your city. How very cool.