Skip to content

“I’ve Given God Plenty to Contend With”

I recently had a conversation with a colleague from another part of the country about how to deal with someone in pastoral leadership who is struggling with addictions of various sorts. Yes, pastors are sinners like everyone else, but there is (understandably and usually rightly) an expectation that those in spiritual leadership should be setting an example, at least on some level. Most people don’t expect moral perfection (well, some seem to, truth be told), but it’s not crazy to expect that your pastor isn’t neck deep in vice as he or she stands in front of you on Sunday morning.

We batted this tension around for a while. Pastors are sinners in need of grace just like those they preach to. Pastors are charged with living into and exemplifying the newness of life that Christ offers. Pastors are real human beings who struggle in all the real human ways. Pastors cannot lead super effectively if they are mired in their own pain and sin. Pastors should be allowed to be vulnerable. Pastors shouldn’t bleed all over the pulpit. Back and forth we went. There was plenty of grey in our conversation and not as much black and white as either of us might have preferred. There was always an, “On the other hand…”

Out at the jail on Monday I sat with a guy who was beginning his seventh decade. He’s spent at least forty of those years trawling the depths of human depravity. Drugs, violence, poverty, casual and abusive treatment of women… the list is as along as it is depressing. He has been charged with a bunch of crimes including one very serious one. Like the kind that might make you gasp out loud. He was adamant that he wasn’t guilty, but, well, you know…

I have met with this guy enough over the years to know that the conversation would quite quickly veer off into unhelpful territory if I didn’t do something to change the trajectory. “You say you’ve been reading your bible a lot,” I said. “What have you been reading? What has God been showing you.” He looked at me a bit sideways. Maybe he knew what I was doing, who knows. But he obliged. “Well, I’ve been reading in Jeremiah a lot. And some of the other prophets. And man, those people the prophets were sent to… you know, they gave God a lot to contend with!” He paused. Looked at me again. “And I guess God’s been showing me that, well, I’ve give God a lot to contend with over the years, too. I’m not guilty of everything they’ve charged me with. But I’m guilty of a lot of it. Yeah, I’ve given God plenty to contend with.” 

“That’s a pretty important insight,” I said. “We can’t make any progress toward the light unless we acknowledge the darkness.” He nodded. We talked more about the prophets and about ourselves. We prayed together, asking God to help us give him less to contend with. We said our amens as the guard came to escort him back to his cell. 

I have long been convinced (and have evidently never tired of repeating in this space) that one of the defining needs of our cultural moment (inside and outside the church) is an honest and accurate theological anthropology. We are in desperate need of the language and categories by which to understand ourselves truly and hopefully. We by nature give God plenty to contend with. We are instinctive idolaters, reflexive deniers, and resourceful evaders. We are expert deceivers—of God, others, and ourselves. We are also hardwired for love and want to be holy, even if we struggle to get there. We long for wholeness in all its forms. We are all of these things and more, in various configurations and to varying degrees. We are sinners and saints, wholly dependent upon the God whose love outruns our folly, who does not cease contending with us. 

Later in the afternoon out at the jail this week, we read the story of the woman caught in adultery from John 8. It’s a story that never fails to connect with the inmates, for obvious reasons. The wagging religious fingers are put in their place. The woman is lifted from her shame. Where are your accusers? Has no one condemned you? Then neither do I condemn you. It is a staggering thing for a guilty party to hear. No condemnation. And equally staggering is the last line. Go and leave your life of sin. 

Jesus seems to think it’s possible, at least on some level. Perhaps we should, too. 


Discover more from Rumblings

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

No comments yet

Leave a Reply