Skip to content

Bavaria, Lisbon, and the Problem of Evil

This morning I was washing the dishes, listening to the sounds of my happy children playing (surprisingly!) peacefully together. Some days everything just seems right with the world—the kids aren’t fighting, the sun is shining, I’m not wretchedly behind in my schoolwork, the Flames beat the Oilers last night…

As I was enjoying this pleasant morning, my thoughts drifted to a story I had read the previous night about the devastating storm that hammered northern Europe this week. About halfway through the article, buried amidst news of flight cancellations and infrastructure damage, was the news that the storm had caused a patio door to crash into a baby in Bavaria.

The child died.

Somewhere, an ocean away from my peaceful morning, a family is grieving the loss of a child because of the weather. Somewhere, a mother or father has had the possibility of an ordinary peaceful morning like mine, washing dishes, listening to the sound of their child happily playing, taken from them. I was struck, again, by how absolutely absurd and unjust it is that something so catastrophic and devastating from a human perspective could be the result of things like weather patterns. How do these things happen in a world that I believe is governed by a sovereign God?

About two and a half centuries ago, on All Saints Day in the city of Lisbon, an earthquake had a similar effect upon European consciousness. Nature had produced something so devastating, so incomprehensible, so “evil” from a human perspective, that confidence in God’s providence and sovereignty was shattered. The problem of evil assumed a new position of prominence in academic philosophy and theology, as intellectuals around Europe struggled massively with how the existence of a good and powerful God could be reconciled with the evils—natural and moral—experienced by human beings? Some came up with creative, if quite technical and complex, answers. Others gave up on the project altogether – deciding that it was impossible that a good God would allow 60-100 000 people to die as a result of things like earthquakes.

The storm experienced by northern Europe this week was not nearly so devastating—it certainly does not merit comparison with the Lisbon earthquake of 1755. Compared to Lisbon, the number of casualties resulting from this storm is microscopic (10, if I’m not mistaken). I suspect that for most Europeans life will (if it hasn’t already) return to normal this week.

But not for one family in Bavaria.

Most days I can come up with good reasons for believing that evil is explainable as a part of a good world made by a gracious God. But today, as I enjoy the happy sounds of my children playing and think about total strangers who will never have that chance again, it’s hard.

4 Comments Post a comment
  1. thanks

    January 22, 2007
  2. renita hamm #

    Sometimes I’m fortunate enough to get a glimpse into what your ponderings are. And if being left with more questions than answers is a blessing??, then I am blessed indeed to be able to ponder with you.

    January 31, 2007
  3. Hi Renita! It’s great to hear from you. Like you, I think that being left with more questions than answers can certainly be a blessing… Sometimes… I think…

    The problem of evil is something that has dominated my thinking for some time now – I’m even investigating the possibility of writing a thesis on the subject, so I expect the “blessings” will continue.

    January 31, 2007
  4. renita #

    What? Are you doing a thesis already? Are you almost done at Regent? You are brilliant!

    Aaah, the problem of evil. Is the presence of evil the same as the absence of good? Is goodness evidence of the presence of God? When evil takes over does that mean God is absent? What does Omnipresent mean anyway? Or is it just that God is not powerful enough to keep little children safe from storms?

    Oh dear, too many questions (I mean, blessings!). And too limited a mind to figure this stuff out. Good for you for trying though, Ryan.

    February 12, 2007

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s